在某人有过打父亲的情况下，讨论他是否已经停止了打父亲的问题是不会产生逻

在某人有过打父亲的情况下，讨论他是否已经停止了打父亲的问题是不会产生逻辑困难的。但是，在某人不曾有过打父亲的情况下，讨论他是否已经停止了打父亲的问题就是不合理的，而我们所面临的情况正好类似于后者。

When someone has beaten his father, there is no logical difficulty in discussing whether he has stopped beating his father. However, when someone has never beaten his father, it is unreasonable to discuss whether he has stopped beating his father, and the situation we face is just similar to the latter.

When someone has beaten his father, there is no logical difficulty in discussing whether he has stopped beating his father. However, it is unreasonable to discuss whether someone has stopped beating his father before, and the situation we are facing is just like the latter.