Each method‟s results are mechanically consistent with one another in terms of rank ordering of shear modulus. Within the range of interest, PG 70-22 mastic has the highest shear relaxation modulus and PG 64-22 has the lowest, for both methods. Farther to the right on the relaxation mastercurve, the loading frequencies decrease for longer times as the binderand mastic approach more viscous, Newtonian regions. Around room temperature, the nanoindentation results accurately predict the DSR results for relaxation modulus.